Where to Stay in Nantucket: Top Picks and Hidden Gems


Stay Alfred

Nantucket, a charming island off the coast of Massachusetts, is a popular destination for travelers seeking a picturesque getaway filled with stunning beaches, historic sites, and distinctive local character. With its rich maritime history and classic New England architecture, Nantucket offers visitors a unique blend of relaxation and adventure. In this article, we’ll explore some of the best places to stay on the island to help you plan your perfect Nantucket vacation.

Downtown Nantucket is an excellent choice for first-time visitors, offering a lively atmosphere in the heart of the island’s historic district. Here, you can find a variety of boutique hotels, inns, and bed & breakfasts to suit every budget and taste, all within walking distance from local attractions, shops, and restaurants. For a more tranquil experience, consider staying in Siasconset Village (Sconset), a charming fishing village with a reputation for safety and picturesque ocean views. You can even opt for accommodations in quieter areas, like Tom Nevers or the more remote northeastern tip of the island, where you can find exclusive hotels like The Wauwinet.

No matter where you choose to stay in Nantucket, you’ll find a variety of things to do and see, from exploring the Whaling Museum or taking a leisurely bike ride along the coastline to indulging in fresh seafood at a waterfront restaurant. So, pack your bags, and get ready to immerse yourself in the enchanting world of Nantucket.

Top Nantucket Neighborhoods


Siasconset, commonly known as ‘Sconset, is a quaint Nantucket neighborhood located on the eastern coast of the island. With classic, rose-covered cottages, picturesque beaches, and the Sankaty Head lighthouse, ‘Sconset showcases the historic charm of Nantucket. Enjoy leisurely beach days, a scenic bluff walk or grab a bite at the quintessential Claudettes cafe.

Things to do:

  • Sankaty Head Lighthouse
  • ‘Sconset Bluff Walk
  • Beach picnics


Mid-Island offers a more residential and budget-friendly atmosphere while still providing convenient access to various shops, dining options, and activities. Discover the Maria Mitchell Association’s Loines Observatory for stargazing nights, and learn about Nantucket’s unique natural history at the Linda Loring Nature Foundation.

Things to do:

  • Stargazing at Loines Observatory
  • Visit Linda Loring Nature Foundation
  • Shopping and dining

Brant Point

Located near the entrance of Nantucket Harbor, Brant Point is home to the iconic Brant Point Lighthouse. The neighborhood offers luxurious accommodations and stunning views of the harbor. Enjoy waterfront activities and the nearby Jetties Beach.

Things to do:

  • Brant Point Lighthouse
  • Jetties Beach
  • Boating and watersports


The heart of Nantucket, Town offers a vibrant mix of historic sites, upscale shopping, and art galleries. Cobblestone streets, the Whaling Museum, and numerous dining options make it an excellent location to experience Nantucket’s charm.

Things to do:

  • Nantucket Whaling Museum
  • Shopping and dining
  • Art galleries


Polpis, located on Nantucket’s eastern shore, offers a serene atmosphere with stunning natural beauty. Enjoy birdwatching, hiking, and fishing at the Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge. Discover the rich history of the Life-Saving Museum and wind down with scenic bike rides.

Things to do:

  • Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge
  • Life-Saving Museum
  • Hiking and biking


Madaket, on Nantucket’s western tip, is known for its gorgeous sunsets and pristine beaches. Experience a laid-back and secluded atmosphere perfect for relaxation, and try your hand at surfcasting along the shoreline.

Things to do:

  • Beach days
  • Surfcasting
  • Sunset watching

Types of Accommodation

Nantucket offers a variety of lodging options to cater to different budgets and preferences. Whether you are looking for a luxurious hotel or a cozy bed and breakfast, the island has something for everyone.


There are many hotels in Nantucket offering comfortable stays and a variety of amenities. Some popular choices include The Wauwinet and Beachside on Nantucket. These hotels cater to various needs, such as providing free WiFi, outdoor pools, and even unique amenities like honeymoons.

Bed and Breakfasts

Nantucket is home to a number of charming bed and breakfasts. These establishments generally offer in-town locations and friendly service. Many of them are converted whaling-era mansions with modern conveniences, while others are brand new. The hosts of these establishments are often able to help make their guests’ stay extra special. Find a list of Nantucket B&Bs here.


Inns offer a quaint, more intimate stay, often with a personalized touch. Like bed and breakfasts, inns in Nantucket can be found in-town or off the beaten path. There are various options, including converted historic buildings and new constructions, providing a wide variety for guests to choose from.

Vacation Rentals

For visitors seeking a self-catered and more private experience, vacation rentals are an excellent option. They come in various types, such as apartments, houses, or even luxurious estates. Visitors can rent properties for short term or longer stays. You may book directly with the property owner or use popular platforms such as Airbnb, VRBO, or HomeAway.


Although not as prevalent as other accommodation types, Nantucket does offer some hostels for budget-minded travelers. These establishments provide simple accommodations, often with shared rooms and amenities, making them ideal for those looking to save money and meet fellow travelers.

Fun Fact or Interesting Story

Nantucket is a beloved destination for vacationers, partly due to its historical charm. Did you know that Nantucket is a National Historic Landmark District? The island has preserved many of its 18th and 19th-century buildings, providing a unique and picturesque experience for visitors to the island.

Things to do

While visiting Nantucket, be sure to explore the island’s many attractions, such as its beaches, museums, and shopping districts. Additionally, consider taking a scenic bike ride, whale watching tour, or enjoying the island’s vibrant culinary scene. With its rich history and natural beauty, Nantucket offers countless opportunities for an unforgettable getaway

Factors to Consider When Choosing Accommodation


Your budget plays an important role in deciding where to stay in Nantucket. There are various options available ranging from budget hotels to luxury resorts. For example, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, consider staying at 21 Broad. On the other hand, if you prefer more luxurious accommodations, the White Elephant Nantucket might be the perfect choice for you.

Traveling Group Size

The size of your traveling group significantly affects your choice of accommodation. If you’re traveling with a large group or family, renting a house might be the most suitable option, as it provides more space and the opportunity to cook your meals, saving money in the process. Smaller groups or couples might prefer boutique hotels or charming inns, such as the Martin House Inn.


Nantucket offers diverse locations to suit different preferences:

  • Downtown Nantucket: Rich in history, culture, and shopping opportunities, staying downtown offers easy access to various attractions. Consider staying at the Union Street Inn for a cozy boutique experience.
  • Harbor Area: If you’re fond of picturesque waterfront views and easy access to boat tours or water activities, the Harbor Area is the place to be. An excellent option is The White Elephant, with two properties to choose from.


Amenities are crucial for ensuring a comfortable stay. Make sure to assess which facilities are essential for you and your group, such as:

  • Free WiFi
  • Complimentary breakfast
  • On-site dining
  • Pool or spa facilities
  • Pet-friendly accommodations

Don’t forget to check the reviews and ratings of the hotels to gain insights on their amenities and overall guest experience.

Fun Fact or Interesting Story

Did you know that Nantucket used to be the whaling capital of the world? Its rich whaling history is evident in the preserved 18th and 19th-century architecture, cobblestone streets, and the Whaling Museum, making it a unique destination to explore its past while enjoying modern-day comforts.

Things to do

While staying in Nantucket, there are plenty of activities to keep you entertained:

  • Visit the historical sites, such as the Oldest House or the Old Mill
  • Explore the beautiful beaches, like Surfside or Cisco Beach
  • Take a bike tour to discover the picturesque landscapes and hidden gems of the island
  • Participate in water activities like sailing, kayaking, or paddleboarding.

Enjoy your stay in Nantucket!

Popular Accommodation Options

Nantucket offers a diverse range of accommodation options for travelers with different preferences and budgets. In this section, we will explore some popular choices among luxury hotels and resorts, mid-range hotels, and budget-friendly options.

Luxury Hotels and Resorts

If you’re looking for a luxurious stay, Nantucket has some top-notch options to cater to your needs. Some of the most popular luxury hotels include:

  • The Wauwinet: Known for its popularity among honeymooners, The Wauwinet offers a 4.5-star hotel experience, free parking, and free WiFi. This upscale property ensures a comfortable and unforgettable stay.
  • White Elephant Hotel: This beautiful waterfront hotel offers a range of amenities such as parking, free Wi-Fi, a pool, and a spa. The stunning views and impeccable service make it a top choice for luxury seekers.

Mid-Range Hotels

For those seeking a balance between luxury and affordability, Nantucket has a number of mid-range hotels to choose from. Some noteworthy options are:

  • The Nantucket Hotel and Resort: An excellent choice for families, this hotel provides a memorable stay with modern amenities and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
  • Union Street Inn: A historic boutique hotel with individually decorated rooms, this quaint inn offers a cozy and elegant stay within walking distance of the town center.

Budget-Friendly Options

Travelers seeking budget-friendly accommodations can still enjoy a lovely stay on the island. Consider these options for an affordable yet comfortable experience:

  • The Beachside at Nantucket: This affordable and well-rated hotel offers parking, free Wi-Fi, and a pool, making it a great budget-friendly choice for your Nantucket getaway.
  • Nantucket Inns and Bed & Breakfasts: Various inns and B&Bs offer in-town locations with appealing amenities, some in converted whaling-era mansions, providing an affordable and charming stay on the island.

Fun Fact or Interesting Story

Did you know that Nantucket has a rich history as a whaling hub that dates back to the 17th century? In fact, the island was once considered the “Whaling Capital of the World.” The historic district boasts well-preserved architecture, offering a glimpse into the island’s fascinating past.

Things to do

While visiting Nantucket, don’t miss out on activities such as exploring the iconic lighthouses, visiting the Nantucket Whaling Museum, strolling down cobblestone streets lined with boutiques and galleries, and enjoying the beautiful beaches that surround the island.

Dining and Entertainment near Accommodation

When you’re staying in Nantucket, you’ll find plenty of dining options and entertainment to keep you busy. In close proximity to many hotels and inns, you’ll discover fabulous restaurants and engaging activities that cater to a range of tastes and preferences.

For a start, Nantucket boasts a wide selection of eateries that span from casual cafes to fine dining establishments. Some top picks include:

  • Cru, renowned for its seafood dishes and remarkable waterfront views
  • The Galley Beach, a beachside restaurant offering a variety of seafood and American fare
  • Lola 41, a trendy sushi and seafood spot with a lively atmosphere

In addition to great food, you can enjoy an exciting nightlife scene in downtown Nantucket. A few popular bars and pubs are:

  • The Club Car, perfect for inventive cocktails and live music
  • Cisco Brewers, a unique brewery, winery, and distillery providing a fun, outdoor setting

In terms of entertainment options, Nantucket has plenty to offer. For a fun fact or interesting story, did you know that Nantucket is home to the oldest working windmill in America? The Old Mill was built in 1746 and is a fascinating spot to visit. Apart from historical tours, some other must-see attractions and things to do in Nantucket include:

  • Whale watching tours to observe these majestic creatures up close
  • Exploring the picturesque beaches, such as Surfside Beach and Jetties Beach
  • Visiting the Nantucket Whaling Museum to learn about the island’s maritime history

Overall, Nantucket provides a well-rounded vacation experience with diverse dining, entertainment, and recreational options. Remember to make time for relaxation and exploration as you discover the charm of this beloved island destination.

stay alfred Icon